Key Philosophical Differences Between Organic & Conventional Farming.
Going beyond the superficial differences between organic & conventional farming
When you search for the difference between organic and conventional farming on Google, you might come across something like this: Conventional farming is a system that utilizes technologies like GMOs, synthetic pesticides, herbicides, and synthetic fertilizers for crop production, while organic farming is presented as a system that relies on recycled organic materials, such as animal manure, crop rotations, disease-resistant crop varieties, and avoidance of synthetic pesticides.
While this definition serves the purpose of providing a quick and straightforward answer, it oversimplifies the complex philosophical differences that underlie these two agricultural systems. In this newsletter, I delve deeper into key philosophical principles that set organic and conventional farming apart.
1. Systemic Mindset vs Reductionist Mindset
At the heart of organic farming lies a profound belief in the interconnectedness of nature. Organic farmers approach their work with the intention of working in harmony with natural systems, recognizing that the components within their farms are interconnected and that these interactions influence the entire farm’s behavior
Organic farmers adopt a systemic mindset, understanding that their farms are intricate ecosystems where each element is intertwined with the others. They view problems holistically, recognizing that any issue is part of a larger system. This approach acknowledges the complexity of nature and avoids oversimplification.
Conversely, conventional farming often adopts a reductionist mindset, which simplifies complex problems by breaking them down into smaller, more manageable components. This approach isolates individual parts of a system for analysis. While this mindset offers simplified solutions, it misses the broader picture and long-term implications of actions or decisions.
2. Driven by Biology vs Driven by Chemistry
The term “organic” itself, means “life,” reflecting the belief that life is biology. Organic farming is deeply rooted in biology, emphasizing the intricate relationships between living organisms and the environment. Organic farmers prioritize soil health, biodiversity, and biological interactions as the foundation of sustainable and environmentally friendly agricultural practices.
For instance, they employ techniques like composting, cover cropping, and crop rotation, all of which enhance microbial diversity, promote the growth of beneficial microorganisms, and improve nutrient cycling and soil structure.
Conventional farming, in contrast, places a stronger emphasis on chemistry, often with a focus on providing plants with the necessary chemical nutrients. The reductionist view in conventional farming often seeks quick solutions by isolating individual components for analysis.
This approach can lead to the overuse of synthetic chemicals and the development of technologies like GMOs, which view life through a reductionist lens, simplifying complex biological interactions and potentially having unintended consequences on ecosystems.
3. Living Soil vs Dead Soil
One of the core differences between organic and conventional farming is how they perceive the soil. Organic farmers regard soil as a living, dynamic ecosystem, rich with microbial life. They nurture the soil by enriching it with organic matter, such as compost, cover crops, and decaying plant and animal materials.
This organic matter serves as a food source for microorganisms, beneficial bacteria, fungi, and enzymes. The activities of these microorganisms play a crucial role in breaking down organic matter, improving soil structure, and making nutrients available to plants.
In contrast, conventional farming often views soil as a passive medium for plant growth, focusing on providing chemical nutrients to plants. Synthetic fertilizers, used extensively in conventional farming, are often considered “dead” nutrients because they provide essential elements in an inorganic, chemical form, without the living organic matter and microbial life found in organic farming.
In Conclusion:
While the simplified definitions available online offer a quick answer to the difference between organic and conventional farming, I think it’s essential to explore the underlying philosophical principles that shape these two agricultural systems. Understanding these core beliefs helps us appreciate the deeper meaning of these farming practices, shedding light on why they differ in their approaches to agriculture.
By recognizing the systemic mindset, biological focus, and reverence for living soil that defines organic farming, we can engage in a more meaningful and informed discussion about the choices we make in our agricultural practices and their consequences on the world around us.
***********
Sincerely, The Organic Guy.
Quick Hits
Podcasts Episodes You Might Have Missed!
My Organic Product Of The Week Series!
This is a weekly series in which I will be sharing with you my organic product of the week. My hope is that by the end of the year, you will be inspired by the amazing variety of organic products that there is to choose from! - So be sure you have subscribed to my YouTube channel or you are following me on Instagram to ensure you don’t miss any updates!
Organic & Science
Organic and Science is a series of posts I release every Monday to highlight peer-reviewed science that supports organic some of which most scholars probably don't want you to see. Always be on the lookout for that. And if you are NOT following me on social media, Do so here!
Till the NEXT one, Be Organic.